How we pick
Every guide on GiftReasons follows the same rules, and the site's build checks hold each guide to them before it goes up. This page sets them out.
Where the facts come from
- What a product is, what comes with it and who it suits are taken from the maker's or the store's own published page. Each of those pages is listed in the guide's sources with the date it was read.
- Every pick links to a US store or to a maker's own US site, where it was for sale when the page was read.
- A guide is built from these published details. It makes no claim that anyone has used the products.
- Before a guide goes up, a second reader who did not write it checks it against its sources.
What every pick must have
- A reason: why it suits the person the guide is for.
- A "skip if" line: who it is the wrong gift for.
- Tags for the guide's own splits, such as the kind of hobby and how far along the person is, or the occasion and whether the gift is for one person or a team.
- A price band, or "Price varies".
Price bands, not prices
Store prices change, so a pick shows one of three price bands instead of a price. A band comes from the price a maker or a store other than Amazon listed when its page was read, and the read date is shown beside it. When no such price was read, or the giver picks the amount (a gift card), the pick shows "Price varies".
The rules for each guide
- Between 20 and 35 picks, chosen from at least one and a half times as many gifts. The count considered is shown at the top of the guide, and the ones left out are recorded with the reason.
- Picks from at least four different stores or makers, no more than three from one maker, and no more than half sold only on Amazon.
- No overall winner, no scores and no rankings, and nothing about how popular a product is or how many are left.
- A hobby guide says what not to buy, and puts first the safe picks for a giver who does not know the person's gear: things that get used up, experiences, gift cards and books.
Keeping guides current
The date at the top of a guide is the earliest date on which its picks' availability and prices were read, so it is true of every pick. The site's checks refuse a guide whose date is more than six months old, so a guide is read again before then.
Photos
Where a pick has a photo, it is the maker's or the store's own picture of that product, kept on this site and credited under the picture. No photo comes from Amazon.
Commission and picks
A store's commission does not decide what is picked. The disclosure explains how the site is paid.